STORIES

PENALTIES AND PANTIES


It started with a fire drill.

A cool Friday morning in early November, just crisp enough that the breath of 700 restless teenagers at Jim Bowie High School rose like low-lying fog across the football practice fields.

Mason McCullough stood with his hands stuffed deep in the pockets of his letterman jacket, jaw tight, eyes shaded under a mop of dark, uncombed hair that curled over his ears. Mason had the kind of face that belonged in a high school yearbook under “Most Likely to Make Bad Decisions Look Good”, with permanent shadows under his eyes from too many late-night drives and too little sleep. His build—broad-shouldered and rangy from four years of football—still carried the wiry defiance of a boy not quite ready to grow all the way up.

Across the blacktop, Shannon Hudspeth twirled a piece of hair around one manicured finger, laughing too loud at something a couple of guys from Auto Tech said. She was seventeen going on thirty-seven, with hips that knew how to sway and a mouth that knew when to pout and when to smirk. Her hair was the kind of blonde you could tell came from a bottle but didn’t seem to mind. Freckles dusted her nose, and her jeans looked like they’d been poured on. The faint trace of Love’s Baby Soft perfume followed her like a rumor.

Next to the fence, Whiskey Jack—real name Daniel Jack, but only the school secretary still called him that on accident—leaned with the loose, defeated slouch of someone used to ducking flying objects at home. His sandy brown hair sat crooked on his head, like it hadn’t met a brush in weeks, and his eyes stayed downcast more often than not. A faded denim jacket hung off his narrow frame, and the permanent split in his bottom lip—a leftover from last summer’s “Dad and a Dinner Plate” incident—gave him a look of accidental toughness he hadn’t earned.

“She’s laying it on thick today,” Whiskey mumbled, jerking his chin toward Shannon.

Mason just shook his head. Shannon Hudspeth had that effect on people. On him too, if he was being honest.

There had been Kristen Nolan. There had been promises. And then there had been that night in the press box over the fifty-yard line, with bourbon breath, football field dew, and Shannon sliding into his life like a bad decision with painted nails and cherry lip gloss.

That morning, everyone out on the football field lined up by homeroom class, Shannon caught Mason’s eye like she’d done a hundred times before. Smiled. Tilted her head. And just like that, Mason had an idea.

“Hey,” Mason said, turning to Whiskey. “You feel like being useful?”

Whiskey shrugged. “Depends.”

Mason nodded toward the parking lot. “See that Buick?”

Coach Rockdale’s 1971 Buick Centurion Convertible sat out by the visitor lot, dropped white top folded behind the rear seats like it hadn’t seen daylight use in weeks. Burnished Cinnamon paint caught the light in places and bubbled with rust in others. The whole car had the proud, battered look of something that had seen better days but still had enough left under the hood to break your nose if you doubted it.

“The coach’s ride?” Whiskey blinked. “You’re kidding.”

“I’m not.”

“What are we doing?”

Mason grinned. “Settling a score.”

Whiskey let out a slow, defeated breath. “Hell. Alright.”

Mason walked over to Shannon, whose hips shifted like a dare as she pretended not to notice him until he was two feet away.

“You still got those red panties on?” he asked, like he was talking about weather patterns.

Her eyes narrowed, playful and dangerous all at once. “Why?”

“I need ‘em.”

Her smile curled. “Now or later?”

“Now.”

Ten minutes later, while Principal Pough counted heads near the Home Ec room entrance and the rest of the school waited for the all-clear bell, Shannon ducked behind the backseat of the Centurion, smooth as a cat burglar.

Whiskey stood lookout by the AG Building, kicking gravel and pretending to study the horizon like he was expecting enemy aircraft.

The Buick’s doors weren’t locked—Coach Rockdale’s trust in small-town teenage virtue proving to be wildly misplaced. The top, permanently lowered thanks to a half-dead hydraulic pump and two years of deferred maintenance, gave Shannon easy access.

With a practiced tug and a shimmy, she peeled them off under her skirt, popped the glovebox open with one hand, and slid the red silk right in there next to a half-dead flashlight and a greasy registration form.

Click. Shut. Done.

The three of them stood back near the light pole, barely containing their laughter.

“Think he’ll notice right away?” Whiskey asked.

Mason smirked. “Not till the next time he takes the Mrs. somewhere romantic.”

“Or the next time he goes fishing for napkins,” Shannon said, sticking out her tongue.

They all laughed again.

The bell rang. Everyone went back inside.

And that should’ve been the end of it.

But nothing stays buried in Fort Stockton. Especially not panties in a glovebox.

The following Friday evening, there sat the Buick—top still down as always—under the Dairy Twin’s buzzing neon sign. Coach Rockdale in his faded Adidas polo, sneakers stained with chalk dust from practice, trying to herd his toddler son into a plastic picnic booth.

Mrs. Rockdale—brunette, sharp-shouldered, with the permanent expression of a woman three years past her patience threshold—dug around the glovebox for a napkin.

What she pulled out… was not a napkin.

The red panties dangled from her fingers like a surrender flag at the Scuttlebutt Gentleman’s Club.

Coach Rockdale froze mid-step, strawberry soft-serve dripping off the kid’s chin.

Whiskey choked so hard on his Dr Pepper that Mason had to slap him on the back till he could breathe.

Mrs. Rockdale climbed into her Monte Carlo with their boy, slammed the door hard enough to make the Dairy Twin windows rattle, and burned rubber out of the lot, leaving the Cinnamon Buick and one stunned football coach standing there like Exhibit A.

By sunrise Saturday, half the high school knew. By Monday, all of Fort Stockton did.

Coach Rockdale vanished from his duplex by the water tower and reappeared at the Naughty Pine Motel by Tuesday, registered under “J. Robertson” and paying cash for a room with a broken heater and a cracked mirror above the bathroom sink.

Practice that week turned from bad to biblical.

Wind sprints till dark. Full-pad Oklahoma drills on a Wednesday. One day of running stairs until half the team puked behind the bleachers—including two guys from the offensive line who hadn’t run that hard in their entire lives.

“We’re gonna do this until somebody confesses,” Rockdale growled, pacing like a bear with a migraine, mirrored Ray-Bans on, whistle swinging like a noose from one thick finger.

No one did.

Not on Mason. Not on Whiskey. And definitely not on Shannon Hudspeth, who sat at the edge of the bleachers most afternoons, legs crossed, pretending to read a dog-eared copy of Valley of the Dolls.

Coach Rockdale suspected everyone. Linebackers, tight ends, even the backup kicker.

Rumors spread like mesquite smoke in dry season. Some kids blamed Kenny Daniels, others blamed some JV lineman with a grudge over playing time.

But nobody cracked.

By Friday night, the Jim Bowie Fightin’ Knives were lean, mean, and playing like they hadn’t eaten in a week.

Crane High School didn’t stand a chance.

The scoreboard read 28–7 by the third quarter. Coach Rockdale yelled himself hoarse, then paced the sideline like a man half-mad, half-proud, and still fully paranoid.

The win didn’t change much. Not about the glovebox. Not about Mrs. Rockdale.

Not about the whispered rumors that started circulating by Monday that she’d been spending a little too much time at Second Baptist… counseling with Brother Brandon, the new youth pastor, who’d always been a little too eager with the handshake and a little too slow to close the blinds in his office.

After the game, Mason found Shannon leaning against the Coke machine outside the gym, her jean jacket hanging off one shoulder, looking like a country song waiting to happen.

“You’re welcome,” she said, popping her gum and smiling like she hadn’t started a wildfire with a single bad decision.

“For what?” Mason asked, already knowing.

“The playoff win.”

Mason laughed, shaking his head.

Whiskey walked up, sweat still sticking his hair to his forehead, holding three lukewarm Gatorades from the trainer’s cart.

“You know,” Whiskey said between gulps, “if Rockdale finds out it was us…”

“We’re dead,” Mason finished.

Shannon gave them both one last wicked grin.

“Well,” she said, tossing her hair, “then I guess y’all better hope he keeps thinking it was Brother Brandon.”

And with that, she walked off into the night, hips swaying, like she had five husbands waiting in the future and no regrets pulling at her heels.

The Buick sat under the parking lot lights, top still down, paint glinting like burnt sugar and bad ideas.

Some stories start with a whistle. Some with a prayer.

This one started with a fire drill.

And a pair of red panties in a glovebox.



5 responses to “PENALTIES AND PANTIES”

  1. This is Great!! It takes us back to Players from the Past.
    Maybe if I concentrate, I can keep track of all the names this time without the list that I never wrote down in the first place.
    They say that the memory is the 2nd thing to go, but I can’t remember the correct order.
    I just know most of it’s gone.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Captain My Captain

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading