STORIES

MOVIE REVIEW:  A CHRISTMAS STORY


By:  Jimmy Don Ventura

Stockton Telegram-Dispatch Movie Reviewer | Captain My Captain Blog Contributor


The Gospel According to Ralphie

Some folks remember the holidays by the smell of pine needles or Grandma’s stuffing. Me? I remember it by the sound of the Old Man cussing at his car. That’s why A Christmas Story (1983) hits me right in the carburetor every time I watch it. The movie’s about childhood, nostalgia, and that holy trinity of Christmas longing: toys, turkey, and tire chains. But for me—and for the Old Man—it’s also about being an Oldsmobile man.

Gene Shepherd’s narration nails the kind of affectionate mockery that defines American fatherhood in the mid-20th century. When he says, “Some men are Baptists, others Catholics; my father was an Oldsmobile man,” he’s not just talking about a car. He’s talking about a worldview—a whole belief system wrapped in steel and chrome. The Old Man’s religion was internal combustion, and his church was a frozen driveway in northern Indiana (played by Cleveland, Ohio).

The Car That Froze Christmas

The car in question, a 1938 Oldsmobile Touring Sedan, isn’t just background dressing. It’s a full-fledged character in A Christmas Story. It’s there when Ralphie’s fantasy of family bliss shatters into that glorious “Ohhhh fuuuuuuudge” moment during the flat-tire fiasco. It’s there when they drive through the snow, a tree tied precariously to the roof, and it’s parked loyally outside the Chinese restaurant when Christmas dinner takes a turn toward the Peking duck.

Let’s give this beauty its due. The ’38 Olds Touring Sedan had a sticker price of about $900, which sounds like pocket change today but was no small chunk in Depression recovery America. Powered by a straight-six engine sending grunt to the rear wheels, it offered just enough horsepower to haul a family, a Christmas tree, and a trunk full of frozen turkeys through a Midwestern winter. Around 140,000 examples rolled out of Lansing that year—good, honest machines built for families that couldn’t afford a Cadillac but refused to settle for a Chevy.

The particular Oldsmobile in A Christmas Story was donated by a local Cleveland car collector. It now lives on display at the A Christmas Story House & Museum, a pilgrimage site for those who measure Christmas not by shopping lists but by antifreeze viscosity.


Methanol, Mayhem, and the Mechanics of Misery

Let’s talk about that antifreeze. Back in the day, your average Olds cooling system was about as sealed as a West Texas saloon door in July. Drivers relied on methanol-based antifreeze, which had the irritating habit of evaporating faster than a politician’s promise. You had to keep topping it off, especially when the temperature dropped. Shepherd’s narration perfectly captures that old-timer frustration when the Old Man bellows:

“That hot damn Olds has froze up again! That son of a bitch would freeze up in the middle of summer on the equator!”

That line is poetry. Pure combustion-powered poetry. And it’s accurate. The poor guy was fighting chemistry with a wrench and a prayer. These days we use ethylene glycol, a far more stable coolant, but it doesn’t come with the same aroma of defeat and desperation that defined an American garage in 1940.

You can practically smell it in the movie—the faint blend of gasoline, radiator steam, and frustration. You see, for men like Ralphie’s dad, a frozen engine wasn’t just an inconvenience. It was a personal insult. The car was a symbol of masculinity, self-reliance, and pride. When it failed, it meant the man had failed. And that’s why his curses were practically liturgical.

The Oldsmobile Man’s Gospel

The phrase “Oldsmobile man” carries weight. Oldsmobile was the working man’s luxury—sleek enough to be respectable, sturdy enough to be abused. Its tagline back then could’ve been “You can’t afford to look broke.” For men like the Old Man, that badge meant something. It was a handshake between practicality and pride, a declaration that you had made it far enough to have something that could break down in comfort.

You see, every father of that generation was “a something man.” There were Ford men, Chevy men, Studebaker men, even the occasional Hudson eccentric. Cars weren’t just transportation—they were tribal markings. A man’s loyalty to his make ran deeper than politics or denomination. You could marry outside your religion, but God help you if you brought home the wrong car.

That’s why Shepherd’s line lands so beautifully. When he calls his father an “Oldsmobile man,” it’s both reverence and ribbing. The Old Man’s devotion to his car, even as it betrayed him, mirrors every parent’s devotion to a life that doesn’t always cooperate. He believed in the myth of American engineering with the same fervor that Ralphie believed in Santa Claus. And in both cases, reality occasionally froze up and refused to start.

The Neighborhood Fleet

While the Oldsmobile takes top billing, A Christmas Story quietly serves as a museum of late-1930s and early-1940s automotive Americana. Parked along the snowy curbs of Hohman, Indiana (fictional, but based on Shepherd’s hometown of Hammond), are Fords, Chevrolets, Plymouths, and Dodges that look like they’ve seen better Decembers.

One particularly sharp-eyed moment shows a 1948 Chevrolet Stylemaster and a Ford fire truck, their red paint glowing against the white snow as the schoolyard rescue unfolds—when poor Flick learns the hard way that a frozen flagpole and a wet tongue don’t mix. It’s a beautiful slice of period-correct visual storytelling: every vehicle, every curve of fender and chrome bumper, reinforcing the era’s design optimism before the war turned steel into tanks.

These weren’t just props. They were a time capsule of what cars used to represent: adventure, independence, and mechanical intimacy. You could fix them with a wrench and a bad attitude. And when they finally gave up the ghost, you pushed them into the backyard and let the kids play “mechanic,” just like Ralphie’s friend standing in the skeletal remains of a Model A.


When Toys Had Tailfins

Now, speaking of toys—you can’t talk about A Christmas Story without talking about the gift. Not the Red Ryder BB gun, though that gets all the glory, but the gift that I remember most vividly: the Playmobile Dashboard.

Before kids had iPads and touchscreens that make noise when you so much as sneeze, we had toys that trained us to drive. The Playmobile was a child-sized car dashboard, complete with a steering wheel, radio dials, speedometer, and even a pretend key that clicked like the real thing. Introduced in the 1950s and 60s, it gave kids the illusion of piloting their own sedan through an imaginary suburb, complete with turn signals and the occasional horn honk that drove parents to the brink of homicide.

The version I got one Christmas—long before Ralphie’s cinematic debut—had a red and silver dashboard and a faux “deluxe” badge that made me feel like I owned a Buick. The speedometer needle would bounce as you “drove,” the heater controls clicked, and the gear lever proudly displayed P-D-L-R (because who needs “N,” right?).

I must’ve “driven” a million miles across the living room carpet, narrating my own adventure like Gene Shepherd on a sugar rush. My mom said I’d sit there for hours muttering things like, “Gonna have to replace that muffler” or “She’s running hot again.” Maybe that’s why I connected so deeply with A Christmas Story. Ralphie wanted his BB gun; I wanted a working transmission.

According to Hemmings, the Playmobile was the ultimate driving simulator for the postwar baby boom. It was realism by way of plastic and imagination—a toy that taught you the thrill of motion without ever leaving the rug. It even came with fake car club decals, just in case you wanted to look like the president of the junior Oldsmobile Owners Association.


Why It Endures

The brilliance of A Christmas Story lies in its refusal to grow up. It’s a film that remembers how big the world looked when you were three feet tall and wearing too many layers. It treats the Old Man’s curses, the mother’s patience, and the kids’ obsessions with equal parts comedy and tenderness. There’s no moral lesson shoehorned in—just the warm ache of remembering.

And those cars—the Olds, the Chevys, the fire truck—are extensions of that memory. They creak, they smoke, they freeze, they stall. But they also move. They carry the family from one misadventure to the next, and that’s all any family vehicle needs to do: get you to Christmas dinner, even if it’s at a Chinese restaurant called Bo Ling’s.

The Old Man’s Oldsmobile embodies the film’s whole philosophy. Life is unreliable, messy, sometimes frozen solid, but we keep driving anyway. We patch the radiator, curse the carburetor, and keep moving toward whatever’s next.


Epilogue: Jimmy Don’s Garage Philosophy

When I think about Ralphie’s dad yelling at that Oldsmobile, I see my own father under the hood of a Ford pickup, knuckles bleeding, steam rising, muttering words you won’t find in the New Testament. Every generation has its version of that moment—the father vs. the machine. And every kid grows up believing that somewhere, in the mystery of those busted engines, lies the secret to adulthood.

These days, I drive something with heated seats and Bluetooth, but every December, when A Christmas Story comes on, I find myself longing for simpler frustrations. I miss the way cars used to have faces—grilles that smiled, headlights that winked. I miss dashboards with real switches instead of screens. And I miss the smell of antifreeze mingling with pine needles in a cold garage.

Maybe that’s what Shepherd meant to capture all along—not the story of a boy and his BB gun, but the story of a family defined by its quirks, its laughter, and its barely-running Oldsmobile. The film reminds us that nostalgia isn’t about perfection—it’s about persistence.

So this Christmas, when you see that Olds struggling through the snow, give a little nod. That car’s doing what we’re all trying to do: keep going, even when the coolant’s low, the tire’s flat, and your best efforts are met with a string of unprintable words.

And as Shepherd himself might say, in that wry radio tone that sounds like bourbon and static:

“In the end, we always got there. Maybe not on time, maybe not in one piece—but we got there.”

That’s A Christmas Story in a nutshell.
A frozen, funny, four-door reminder that the journey—like a good Oldsmobile—is what keeps the holidays rolling.

The Final Verdict: Jimmy Don’s Christmas Pine Rating

On the Jimmy Don Movie Rating Scale, A Christmas Story earns 4½ out of 5 Christmas Pines.

It loses that half a cane only because the Olds never quite gets the respect it deserves (and because Jimmy Don still believes the family should’ve carried a spare jug of antifreeze in the trunk). Everything else—from Shepherd’s narration to the snow-slick cinematography and the unforgettable one-liners—runs smoother than a freshly rebuilt Stromberg carb.

Why 4 Christmas Pines: 🎄🎄🎄🎄

  • Storytelling: Warm, nostalgic, timeless.
  • Automotive Accuracy: Spot-on for the period, right down to the tire chains and cold cranks.
  • Acting: Perfectly awkward in all the right ways.
  • Holiday Spirit: Strong enough to defrost a windshield.
  • Bonus Points: For reminding every “Oldsmobile man” that family and frustration often come standard, no extra charge.

In Jimmy Don’s book, that’s a certified Christmas classic—best enjoyed with cocoa, crankcase fumes, and a front-row parking spot for your inner child.



6 responses to “MOVIE REVIEW:  A CHRISTMAS STORY”

  1. I can do little more than echo comments already shared – so very correct and apropos.
    When we note “Jimmy Don still believes the family should’ve carried a spare jug of antifreeze in the trunk”,
    are we forgetting the era and it’s typical containers? Plastic resealable jug of Zerone (cheaper than Zerex)? Yes, there was a difference in capability for the cheaper wood (methyl) alcohol , VS “Permanent” Ethylene Glycol anti-freeze – BUT they came in a can. We opened the can – either a quart size, or if you just got paid maybe a full gallon size – with a Church Key – the old fashioned can opener with a tang to hold the edge, and a sharp triangular tip to pierce and cut the metal top of the can. Later, even cardboard cans still had a metal top. Resealable plastic jugs came much later. So, maybe, other than the expense, that’s why the “Old Man” didn’t carry a spare jug of anti-freeze in the trunk? Money was tight, a punctured can was inconvenient, and it wouldn’t fit the story anyhow~!
    Still, a Christmas Story is among my favorites, and the Flag Pole scene is Classic.

    Looking toward Christmas Day in the 80s, I don’t miss the slush –
    Family and friends are what counts, and driving River Road in a convertible to enjoy the bonfires, anticipating Pere Noel coming up the river and the bayou in his batteau (or pirogue), bringing toys for Cajun children is a great way to celebrate the season, and then back home to celebrate with Cajun seasonings – gumbo, jambalaya, and oyster stuffing for the turkey, and for desert – a half-chocolate and half-lemon doberge 7-layer cake with chocolate and lemon pudding between the layers – topped off with either Bailey’s or Harvey’s Bristol Cream Sherry.

    Wishing all, the best, and the chance to be with those we appreciate.

    • “…Pere Noel coming up the river and the bayou in his batteau (or pirogue)…”

      I always heard that Santa arrived in a mudboat.

    • Marty, I think I have already told this — but my wife was from Beaumont, and when we were dating, she told me about slipping over the border in high school to Big Oaks (or was it Big Annes), where kids could drink and dance and, you know, have fun! She took me there a couple of times. Cajuns are great folks!

  2. “You’ll shoot your eye out.” I can still hear my father, also an Oldsmobile man, saying the same thing. Best Christmas movie evah.

  3. The best Christmas movie of the the late 20th century…Period. hands down, end of story, that’s a wrap.
    It’s a wonderful life, best of the early 20th century
    Bing Crosby best mid century; post war optimism and all

    I will only watch A Christmas story, every other year to make it somewhat fresh…and it never fails, oh and this year is an “on” year. fire in the fire place, hot toddy in my liver spotted hand and still laughing hard at the flag pole scene…
    and in the end always a tug at the heart strings of nostalgia of a better time(imagined most likely, but still a better time)
    thanks Cap, oops i mean Don, for reminding me that I am old ..
    Merry Christmas to you and the fellas

Leave a Reply to MARTY ROTHCancel reply

Discover more from Captain My Captain

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading