STORIES

THE MISTRESS


They met at Pecos Baptist College, which was neither in Pecos nor large enough to justify the confidence with which it used the word College, but it had accreditation, a respectable baseball team, and a chapel requirement that ensured every graduate could locate Habakkuk under moderate pressure.

Daniel Mercer first noticed Emily Carter during an Introduction to Psychology lecture when Professor Haskins asked whether human behavior was primarily the product of nature or environment. Emily raised her hand and gave an answer involving genetics, family structure, personal responsibility and something Daniel didn’t entirely understand about cognitive development. Daniel, who was studying business administration and had spent most of the lecture drawing a Ford pickup in the margin of his notebook, decided immediately that she was the smartest woman he had ever met.

Emily noticed Daniel three weeks later when he held the library door open for her while carrying two books, a backpack and a Styrofoam cup of coffee in one hand.

Their courtship proceeded at the speed prescribed by a small Baptist college in West Texas. There were hamburgers after football games, long conversations in the student center, Sunday evening services, trips to Odessa that qualified as exotic travel, and increasingly elaborate excuses for sitting in Daniel’s aging Ford Ranger after curfew talking about what their lives might someday look like.

They talked about a house.

They talked about children.

They talked about dogs.

They talked about careers and vacations and whether they would someday be the sort of people who owned patio furniture.

Daniel proposed during their senior year. Emily cried before he finished asking. They were married six weeks after graduation at Second Baptist Church of Fort Stockton, where Brother Bob performed the ceremony and privately estimated that Daniel had heard perhaps twelve percent of the sermon because he never stopped looking at his bride.

It was, everybody agreed, a good beginning.

Daniel took a position with a regional building-supply company, eventually moving into commercial sales. Emily went to work in the counseling department at Jim Bowie High School, where her education degree and natural patience made her especially effective with teenagers who had discovered that algebra, acne and romantic rejection could apparently occur simultaneously.

They bought a modest brick house with three bedrooms, two bathrooms and a mortgage that frightened them sufficiently to make adulthood official.

They joined Second Baptist.

Daniel helped with the youth group. Emily organized retreats and Bible studies. Together they became the young married couple parents trusted with their teenagers because they were old enough to be responsible but young enough to understand that a sixteen-year-old boy cannot be expected to make sound theological decisions while standing next to a sixteen-year-old girl.

They also began rescuing dogs.

The first was supposed to be temporary.

Her name was Lucy, a brown mutt from the Fort Stockton Department of Animal Services whose paperwork identified her as a “Lab mix,” which was the phrase the shelter used whenever a dog had four legs and could not otherwise be explained.

Emily brought Lucy home on a Thursday.

Daniel objected until Friday.

By Saturday Lucy was sleeping on his side of the bed.

The second dog was also temporary.

Nobody bothered making that claim about the third.

For several years Daniel and Emily Mercer were exactly what they had hoped they might become when they sat in that Ranger outside the Pecos Baptist dormitory talking after curfew. They worked. They paid bills. They taught Sunday school. They argued occasionally about money, laundry and Daniel’s belief that an empty toilet-paper roll would somehow replace itself if given sufficient time.

Then, one Saturday morning, they went to Frontier Ford-Lincoln-Mercury.

They were going to buy their first new vehicle together.

Daniel had been talking about an F-150 for months. Emily had been listening for considerably less time.

Roger at Frontier Ford knew this.

Roger understood that when a married man came onto the lot announcing that he wanted to “look at trucks,” there were generally two customers involved, only one of whom had spent the previous six months memorizing axle ratios.

Daniel wanted the V8.

Emily wanted heated seats.

Daniel wanted four-wheel disc brakes and enough ground clearance to make New Mexico nervous.

Emily wanted something she could climb into without requiring assistance from the Fort Stockton Volunteer Fire Department.

They found the compromise sitting near the front of the lot.



It was a 2017 Ford F-150 XLT in Ingot Silver, brand new and almost painfully clean. Daniel walked around it twice before opening a door. He ran his hand along the bedside. He looked underneath. He opened the hood and stared at the 5.0-liter V8 with the expression Emily remembered from their wedding day, although she elected not to mention the similarity.

“This is the one,” he said.

“You haven’t driven it.”

“I know.”

“You haven’t asked how much it costs.”

Daniel looked at her.

“Don’t ruin this.”

They drove it anyway.

Emily drove first.

That was Roger’s idea.

By the time they returned to Frontier Ford, she liked the truck almost as much as Daniel did. The cabin was roomy. The air conditioning could freeze cantaloupes. The back seat would hold three teenagers, several rescue dogs or whatever children might eventually come along. Daniel liked the sound of the V8. Emily liked the visibility. Both liked the idea that this was theirs.

They signed papers until their signatures deteriorated into seismographic evidence.

Roger handed Daniel the keys.

Daniel handed them to Emily.

“You drive it home.”

She smiled.

It was a small thing, but marriages are mostly small things. The large promises get made in churches in front of witnesses. The small ones get made in dealership parking lots when nobody is paying attention.

Their daughter arrived eleven months later.

Claire Mercer had her father’s blue eyes and her mother’s disposition. She slept through the night early enough that other new parents considered the Mercers’ good fortune personally insulting. She smiled easily, rarely fussed and regarded the family’s dogs as large, mobile furniture.

There were photographs of Claire asleep against Daniel’s chest. Claire in Emily’s arms at Second Baptist. Claire sitting on a blanket between two rescue dogs. Claire strapped into a car seat in the back of the F-150 while Daniel stood beside the open door grinning like Ford Motor Company had personally designed the rear bench for his daughter.

For a while, the Mercers looked like the photograph that comes inside a picture frame.



Then Daniel met someone.

At first, she wasn’t important.

That was what he would later tell himself.

There hadn’t been any intention behind it. No dissatisfaction with Emily. No plan to jeopardize his marriage. It had simply happened.

A chance encounter.

Then another.

The first few times meant nothing.

Daniel came home afterward and kissed his wife. He picked Claire up and carried her around the kitchen. He fed the dogs. He sat beside Emily on the couch and watched television.

Nothing had changed.

Except something had.

He began thinking about the other one when she wasn’t there.

There was something about being with her that made everything else disappear. Work pressure. Mortgage payments. Church obligations. A crying child. Dogs that needed feeding. A wife who wanted to know why he had been twenty-five minutes late getting home.

With her, none of that mattered.

So there were more encounters.

Some were spontaneous.

Others weren’t.

Daniel learned places where they could be together without interruption. Parking lots. Back roads. An alley behind a warehouse near the railroad tracks. Places where nobody from Second Baptist was likely to see him.

The F-150 took him there.

At first it was still almost factory stock. The silver truck Emily had driven home from Frontier Ford remained the vehicle parked in their driveway beneath the basketball hoop Daniel intended to install when Claire got older.

But Daniel had plans for it.

He always had plans for the truck.

The modifications came gradually.

A suspension upgrade first. Then Fox remote-reservoir shocks. RPG Offroad components. Control arms. Traction bars. An Icon bump-stop kit. FiberwerX fiberglass fenders and bedsides. Addictive Desert Designs bumpers.

The F-150 began climbing.

Then came the blue 17-inch Method Race wheels and 37×12.5-inch BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO2 tires.

Emily stood in the driveway looking up at it.

“Are you expecting Fort Stockton to flood?”

Daniel laughed.

“You never know.”

“We live in the desert.”

“Exactly. Nobody will be prepared.”

She laughed too.

That was still possible then.

The truck received a matte Gunmetal wrap over its Ingot Silver paint. LED projector headlights. Morimoto taillights. Baja Designs auxiliary lights. An ARB air compressor went into the bed beside BuiltRight molle panels, an off-road jack and a full-size spare.

The truck that had once represented their beginning began looking less like the one they had chosen together.

Daniel was changing too.

Emily noticed the absences first.

Twenty minutes.

Forty-five.

An hour.

He started leaving work during the day. Sometimes his employer couldn’t find him. His phone went unanswered. Then Daniel would return with an explanation that was technically possible but somehow never convincing.

Customer meeting.

Lunch ran long.

Needed some air.

Had to pick something up.

Emily wanted to believe him.

Marriage requires trust, but trust has a dangerous weakness: it gives the person being trusted time.

Daniel used that time.



His meetings with the mistress became routine. He knew where to find her. He knew where they could be alone. He learned how long he could stay before somebody began asking questions.

Then she began demanding more.

Daniel gave it to her.

He knew what he was doing was wrong. That knowledge did not stop him. It only added guilt to the list of things he wanted to escape when he was with her.

She gave him something Emily couldn’t.

Not love.

Emily gave him love.

Not companionship.

He had that at home.

The mistress offered something much simpler.

Immediate satisfaction.

No promises. No responsibilities. No tomorrow.

Just now.

And Daniel increasingly lived for now.

Emily found evidence.

Not enough at first.

A receipt that didn’t fit the explanation. A charge on the bank statement. An unexplained withdrawal. A location on his phone that contradicted where he said he’d been. Messages to friends asking them to cover for him.

She confronted him.

Daniel denied everything.

She confronted him again.

He admitted enough to explain what she already knew and denied everything else.

He swore it was over.

And for a while, it was.

Daniel came home on time. He played with Claire. He went back to youth group meetings. He sat beside Emily at Second Baptist while Brother Bob preached about things Daniel tried very hard not to hear.

The mistress stayed away.

Or Daniel stayed away from her.

The distinction mattered.

For several weeks he was almost himself again.

Then one afternoon he thought about her.

That was all.

By evening he was with her.

The relationship resumed with frightening ease.

The F-150 became their accomplice.

Daniel installed a Whipple supercharger on the 5.0-liter V8. There was an aftermarket ECU tune, revised internal components, a Moroso high-capacity oil pan, aluminum oil cooler, Boundary Engineering oil pump, dual JLT catch cans, an aluminum radiator, Ford Performance ignition coils and aluminum valve covers.

The truck became louder, faster and considerably more capable than anything Daniel actually needed.

Power went through the six-speed automatic to 4.56 gears at the rear.

The same truck Emily had once worried might be difficult to climb into could now cross terrain where climbing into it was the least of anybody’s concerns.

Inside, black Katzkin leather replaced the original upholstery. Carbon-fiber-look accents appeared. There was an Edge engine monitor, B&M shifter, rear-camera mirror, auxiliary switches overhead, amplifiers and a subwoofer.

The F-150 was becoming an astonishing machine.

Daniel’s life was becoming a wreck.

He stopped bothering to hide the affair particularly well.

Sometimes he disappeared after work and didn’t come home until morning.

Sometimes Emily called and he simply turned off the phone.

Eventually he began meeting the mistress at the Naughty Pine.

Leon worked nights at the front desk.

The first time Daniel came in, he seemed embarrassed.

Later, he didn’t.

Leon watched him cross the lobby and said nothing. Motel clerks understand that a man’s reasons for needing a room are generally his own until the sheriff asks otherwise.

Daniel would emerge the next morning, climb into the towering gunmetal F-150 and drive home.

Emily knew.

She just didn’t know what to do with knowing.

There was still a little girl who ran to the door when she heard the truck.

“Daddy!”

And Daniel still loved hearing it.

That was the terrible part.

He loved Claire.

He loved Emily.

He loved the dogs.

He loved the house.

He loved the life they had built.

He simply wanted the mistress more.

Love had become irrelevant to the competition.

His parents tried talking to him.

His father chose the direct approach.

“You’re throwing away your family.”

Daniel stared at the floor.

His mother cried.

Brother Bob asked him to come by the church.

Daniel did.

Once.

They sat in Brother Bob’s office for nearly two hours. Daniel admitted what he had done. He admitted he hated himself for it. He said he wanted to stop.

Brother Bob believed him.

That was the problem.

Everybody believed Daniel wanted to stop.

Including Daniel.

Wanting wasn’t enough.

Friends from work tried.

One of them stood beside the F-150 in the employee parking lot and told him exactly what everyone else had.

“She’s going to cost you your wife, your kid, your job and probably that truck.”

Daniel became angry.

The friend didn’t back down.

“She doesn’t love you.”

Daniel knew that too.

He hated her.

He hated what she had done to him.

He hated himself for needing her.

And still, sitting at his desk at work, he would think about the next time they could be together.

He thought about her driving home.

He thought about her sitting in church.

He thought about her lying beside Emily.

Once, while sitting on the living-room floor helping Claire assemble a wooden puzzle, Daniel realized he was thinking about the mistress instead of his daughter.

Claire held up a puzzle piece.

“Daddy, where’s this go?”

Daniel stared at her.

For one clear second he saw everything.

His little girl.

His home.

His wife in the kitchen.

A dog asleep beneath the coffee table.

Everything he had once told Emily he wanted while sitting in an old Ranger outside a college dormitory.

Everything he had.

Everything he was losing.

Daniel started crying.

Claire didn’t understand.

She crawled into his lap and hugged him.

That should have been enough.

It wasn’t.

Eventually Emily gave him the choice.

There was no screaming.

They were beyond screaming.

Claire was asleep.



Emily sat across from Daniel at the kitchen table.

“I can’t do this anymore.”

Daniel said nothing.

“You have to choose.”

He knew what she meant.

“Emily…”

“No.”

He looked at her.

“Your family or her.”

Daniel promised again.

Emily shook her head.

“No promises. Choose.”

He couldn’t.

So Emily chose for him.

Daniel left the house.

He took the F-150.

For the first few nights he slept in the cab.

The black Katzkin leather was less comfortable than it looked.

Then he discovered that the rear bench was marginally better if he curled sideways. His clothes went into a duffel bag. His toothbrush lived in the center console. The rear floorboard collected fast-food sacks.

Seventy thousand miles had accumulated on the digital odometer by then. Most had been added during the years when the truck was Daniel’s pride.

Now it was his address.

The F-150 had everything.

Heated seats.

Automatic climate control.

A supercharged V8.

Long-travel suspension.

Remote-reservoir Fox shocks.

Thirty-seven-inch BFGoodrich tires.

On-board air.

Enough auxiliary lighting to illuminate a small invasion.

What it did not have was a bathroom.

This proved important at three in the morning.

For several weeks Daniel rotated between the truck, friends’ couches and the Naughty Pine.



His parents offered him a room if he would end the relationship.

He wouldn’t.

Friends stopped answering.

His performance at work deteriorated. Customers complained. Appointments were missed. Daniel received warnings.

Then came the anger.

Emily had seen flashes before.

Now there was something different behind it.

Daniel blamed her.

He blamed work.

He blamed his parents.

He blamed Brother Bob.

He blamed Fort Stockton.

Sometimes he even blamed the mistress.

Everybody except Daniel Mercer had somehow become responsible for the life of Daniel Mercer.

The final break came when he returned to the house one evening and demanded to see Claire.

Emily told him no.

Daniel became angry.

Then frightening.

The man standing on her porch was still her husband. She could see traces of the college boy who had held the library door open for her and the young father who had carried their sleeping daughter from the F-150 into the house.

But she could no longer trust him.

And a mother doesn’t get to gamble with her child’s safety merely because she remembers who a man used to be.

Emily closed the door.

Then she locked it.

Daniel stood on the porch for a while.

Finally he walked back to the truck.

The supercharged V8 started with a deep mechanical bark that once would have brought Claire running to the window.

Emily kept her away from it.

The F-150 backed out of the driveway.

The truck was magnificent.

That almost made it worse.

The young couple who had driven home from Frontier Ford years earlier would barely have recognized it. The silver XLT was now a matte Gunmetal long-travel machine sitting high on blue Method wheels and enormous BFGoodrich tires, its fiberglass bodywork stretched around suspension capable of absorbing punishment no ordinary street truck would ever encounter.

It had been strengthened almost everywhere the original Ford might have failed.

Daniel hadn’t.

The divorce took time.

There were forms, hearings, financial disclosures and conversations conducted through attorneys because ordinary conversation had become impossible.

Emily remained at Second Baptist.

Brother Bob never asked her to explain.

People occasionally do the greatest kindness by refusing to demand details they have not earned.

She kept working at Jim Bowie.

She kept rescuing dogs.

Claire grew.

Daniel drifted farther away.

Someone occasionally saw the F-150 outside the Naughty Pine. Someone else saw it parked behind a building near the railroad tracks. A coworker spotted it one afternoon in a vacant lot when Daniel was supposed to be meeting a customer.

Eventually the company let him go.

The truck survived.

Of course it did.

Daniel had spent thousands making sure it could withstand almost anything.

Months later Emily sat with an old college friend at her kitchen table.

There were toys in the living room. One of the rescue dogs was asleep against the back door. Claire’s drawings were attached to the refrigerator with magnets.

Her friend reached across the table.

“You did everything you could.”

Emily looked toward the window.

For years she had wondered what the other woman had that she didn’t.

She had wondered whether she was prettier. Younger. More exciting. Less demanding. She had wondered what kind of woman knowingly took a husband away from his wife and a father away from his daughter.

Eventually Emily understood that those had always been the wrong questions.

There had never been another woman.

Daniel’s secret meetings had been real. So were the lies, the unexplained charges, the missing money, the afternoons in parking lots and alleys, the nights at the Naughty Pine and the mornings when he came home ashamed and promised it would never happen again.

The mistress had been there all along.

Emily looked down at her hands.

“In the end, I had to let him go,” she said. “I could have competed with another woman.”

She looked at her friend.

“But there’s no way I could win against the bottle he fell in love with.”



Leave a Reply

Discover more from Captain My Captain

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading