
A Thanksgiving Movie Review by Jimmy Don Ventura
In which old friends confront their mortality, a funeral becomes a weekend house party, and a man in red sunglasses discovers that the most important thing about growing older is knowing which automobile you should have kept.
There is something fundamentally suspicious about a motion picture in which a group of people gather for a funeral, spend the weekend discussing the disappointments of adulthood, consume substantial quantities of alcohol, and somehow manage to leave feeling better about themselves.
In Fort Stockton, we call that a class reunion.
But Hollywood, having access to better lighting, more expensive real estate, and people who can discuss their emotional shortcomings without somebody suggesting they need a new carburetor, calls it The Big Chill.
Released in 1983 and directed by Lawrence Kasdan, The Big Chill is one of those rare motion pictures that manages to be both profoundly moving and irritatingly self-absorbed, often within the same conversation. It concerns a group of former University of Michigan friends who reunite after one of their number, Alex, commits suicide. What begins as a funeral becomes an extended weekend of nostalgia, confession, recrimination, sexual experimentation, and enough Motown music to keep Detroit solvent for another fiscal quarter.
The surviving friends have reached that uncomfortable stage of adulthood when the people they intended to become have begun filing complaints against the people they actually are.
Some have become wealthy. Some have become famous. Others have discovered that respectability is considerably less satisfying than the college brochures suggested.
Everybody remembers being twenty years old, when the future was still a marvelous, undefined proposition and nobody had yet experienced the humiliation of discovering that a successful career could coexist with a thoroughly disappointing personal life.
I watched the picture again in preparation for this Thanksgiving review, seated in my customary position at the Lucky Lady Lounge, wearing my trademark red sunglasses and accompanied by a bourbon that had already expressed several opinions about the human condition.
I was struck by two things.
First, the movie is considerably better than I remembered.
Second, nearly everybody in it drives something interesting.
Naturally, we’ll concentrate on the second observation, because the first has already been discussed by people who went to graduate school.
The Funeral and the Fleetwood

The picture opens with preparations for Alex’s funeral, and the first automobile worthy of serious consideration is a 1976 Cadillac Fleetwood Series 75.
Now, this is how you transport people who are having an important emotional experience.
The Fleetwood 75 was Cadillac’s magnificent long-wheelbase formal automobile, designed for people who either possessed considerable social standing or had recently ceased needing any. It was enormous, dignified, and equipped with the sort of solemn authority that could make even a trip to the grocery store resemble a state occasion.
The 1976 model was powered by Cadillac’s 500-cubic-inch V8, an engine of such extravagant displacement that modern automobile manufacturers would probably classify it as a municipal power plant.
Speed was never the point. The Cadillac’s purpose was to make the occupants feel that whatever was happening outside the windows was somebody else’s responsibility.
For a funeral, that is an admirable quality.
The funeral establishes the film’s central contradiction. These people once believed they were going to change the world. Now they are riding around in expensive automobiles, wondering whether the world has changed them beyond recognition.
Alex is never fully explained, and that is part of the picture’s intelligence. Everybody remembers a different version of him. The dead man becomes a mirror in which the living examine themselves.
Personally, I would have preferred a little more information about the Cadillac’s maintenance history, but I understand Kasdan had other priorities.
The Jeep That Money Couldn’t Make Comfortable

The weekend takes place at the beautiful South Carolina home of Harold and Sarah Cooper, played by Kevin Kline and Glenn Close.
Harold has made his fortune in athletic shoes. Sarah is a physician. They are prosperous, attractive people who possess a magnificent house and the unsettling ability to make their friends feel inadequate simply by offering them breakfast.
Their automobile is a 1983 Jeep CJ-7 Renegade.
This is an interesting choice for Harold and Sarah.
These are people who could afford practically anything. They have achieved the sort of financial security that allows a person to purchase an automobile specifically designed to be uncomfortable.
The CJ-7 was noisy, primitive, drafty, and possessed of a ride quality suggesting its suspension had been developed by a committee of blacksmiths. Its short wheelbase, removable top, and unapologetically agricultural manners made it considerably more entertaining than practical.
But it allowed affluent people to project an image of rugged unpretentiousness while returning home to a kitchen larger than most apartments.
They have money, but don’t want to appear excessively interested in money. They have succeeded, but would prefer to be regarded as people who haven’t forgotten their idealistic beginnings.
Nothing says we’re still the same people we were in college quite as effectively as a recreational vehicle purchased with the proceeds from a thriving corporation.
And nothing says we’re getting older quite as convincingly as climbing out of a Jeep CJ-7 after a fifty-mile drive and discovering that several important joints have begun negotiating separate retirement arrangements.
A Porsche, a Mercedes, and the Price of Growing Up

The 1969 Porsche 911 Targa is perhaps the most emotionally revealing automobile in the picture.
With its air-cooled flat-six engine mounted behind the rear axle, removable roof panel, and distinctive stainless-steel Targa bar, the Porsche represented a different sort of success from the Cadillac.
It was not about arriving in comfort. It was about enjoying the trip, preferably while reminding everybody else that you were enjoying it considerably more than they were.
The Targa is particularly appropriate in a film populated by people attempting to reconcile youthful enthusiasm with middle-aged responsibilities. It promises that a man can be responsible and irresponsible, successful and adventurous, a respectable adult with a mortgage who still believes a winding road might lead somewhere unexpected.
Unfortunately, a Porsche cannot resolve an existential crisis. It can only make the crisis considerably more enjoyable between curves.
Then we have the 1977 Mercedes-Benz 450 SEL.
Here is an entirely different philosophy of automotive achievement.
The Mercedes W116 sedan was engineered with a seriousness bordering on religious devotion. Its doors closed with the reassuring solidity of a bank vault, its seats were designed for journeys across continents, and its entire personality suggested somebody in Stuttgart had spent several years considering the proper way to manufacture a windshield wiper.
The American-market 450 SEL carried a 4.5-liter V8 and offered mechanical refinement that domestic luxury manufacturers were only beginning to appreciate.
It was expensive, restrained, substantial, and unmistakably successful.
These former radicals have become the very people they once regarded with suspicion. They own expensive houses, drive imported luxury automobiles, and worry about investments, professional reputations, and whether somebody remembered to bring enough wine.
Their younger selves would probably have found them intolerable.
Their older selves would remind their younger selves that somebody had to pay for the wine.
The automobiles illustrate the film’s central tension beautifully.
The Porsche says, I haven’t surrendered.
The Mercedes says, I’ve done rather well.
The Cadillac says, Eventually, none of this matters.
And the Jeep says, Would anybody like to go fishing?
Which is a reasonably comprehensive summary of American adulthood.
The Econoline Arrives Bearing Gifts

One of the more amusing automotive appearances involves a 1975 Ford Econoline delivering Running Dog athletic shoes to the assembled guests.
Running Dog is Harold’s company, and the shoes are his way of extending hospitality while reminding everybody, however unintentionally, that he has become a successful businessman.
Ford’s redesigned 1975 Econoline was the working vehicle of American commerce. Plumbers drove them. Electricians drove them. Delivery companies drove them. Somewhere in Fort Stockton, there was probably one belonging to a man who had been promising to replace its exhaust system since the Carter administration.
And here it is, delivering the physical evidence of Harold’s prosperity to a house full of people who once questioned the moral legitimacy of commercial enterprise.
The revolution has not merely been postponed. It has been fitted with arch supports and distributed in assorted sizes.
Harold’s friends can debate whether they’ve betrayed their youthful ideals, but they’re perfectly willing to accept complimentary athletic shoes.
I’ve always maintained that the surest way to discover the strength of somebody’s political convictions is to offer him free merchandise.
The Econoline brings the outside world into this insulated weekend. Harold’s business exists beyond the conversations and unresolved romantic entanglements. It employs people, manufactures products, and sends delivery vehicles down actual roads.
While everybody else contemplates the meaning of life, somebody has to unload the van.
The Supporting Cast Has Four Wheels

A motion picture like The Big Chill needs background automobiles in much the same way Fort Stockton needs people who have no particular business knowing what everybody else is doing.
They provide atmosphere.
There’s a 1974 Plymouth Valiant, one of Chrysler’s wonderfully durable compacts, purchased by people who had no interest in impressing their neighbors and consequently managed to keep their money.
A 1975 Ford Granada represents Ford’s conviction that Americans would enjoy the prestige of a Mercedes-Benz if somebody could provide it at half the price and with considerably more simulated wood.
The 1973 Chevrolet Suburban offers a more straightforward approach to transportation. Enormous, practical, thirsty, and capable of carrying enough people and luggage to relocate a small religious congregation.
Then there’s a 1976 Chrysler New Yorker Brougham, a magnificent monument to the proposition that American luxury should be measured in pounds, inches, and the amount of vinyl required to cover a roof.
The New Yorker was not so much an automobile as a furnished apartment with license plates.
A 1980 Honda Civic wagon offers the opposite philosophy. Small, efficient, practical, and almost aggressively sensible, it represents the future quietly replacing the New Yorker.
The 1982 Nissan Stanza belongs to that same revolution, when Japanese manufacturers discovered that Americans would purchase smaller automobiles if they started reliably and didn’t require an intimate relationship with the service manager.
There’s also a 1981 Oldsmobile Cutlass, practically mandatory in any American movie of the period, and a 1978 Toyota Celica contributing a little sporting character without the Porsche’s aristocratic pretensions.
Finally, a 1982 Ford LTD-S police car reminds us that whatever personal crises these people are experiencing, the local authorities remain prepared to enforce the speed limit.
This assortment represents the American middle class in transition. Big domestic sedans share the road with smaller Japanese imports. Traditional luxury faces European competition. Practical transportation is no longer necessarily American transportation.
The cars are experiencing the same cultural upheaval as the characters.
Some are adapting. Some are resisting. And some are still driving around with four-barrel carburetors, pretending gasoline costs thirty-five cents a gallon.
I have known people like that.
Several are regulars at the Grounds for Divorce.
The Woman Who Reminded Me of Someone

Now, I should probably say something about the performances.
The ensemble is exceptional. Kevin Kline brings warmth and intelligence to Harold. Glenn Close gives Sarah a quiet emotional authority that keeps the weekend from becoming an extended exercise in affluent self-pity.
William Hurt’s Nick is bitter, wounded, funny, and occasionally insufferable. Jeff Goldblum’s Michael approaches every conversation as though he might eventually sell it to a magazine. Tom Berenger’s Sam has achieved television fame without necessarily achieving personal satisfaction.
JoBeth Williams gives Karen the uncomfortable distinction of obtaining much of what she once wanted and discovering she may have wanted the wrong things.
Mary Kay Place, as Meg, brings vulnerability, intelligence, and determination to a woman who can no longer afford to postpone important decisions.
Which brings us to Mary Beth Hurt.
Now, Mary Beth Hurt is not actually in The Big Chill.
This is a technical detail I discovered after watching the picture, consulting the credits, and spending twenty minutes wondering why the woman I had been admiring looked considerably more like Mary Kay Place than Mary Beth Hurt.
Apparently, I’d been confusing two actresses for approximately forty years.
I don’t regard this as a serious problem. Hollywood has been confusing actresses, actors, and audiences since the invention of synchronized sound.
But Mary Beth Hurt deserves mention because she reminds me of a woman I dated twenty years ago.
And that, unfortunately, brings us to the funeral.
A Funeral, a Girlfriend, and the Trouble With Commercial Refrigeration

Twenty years ago, I was romantically involved with a woman named Darlene Whitcomb.
Darlene was attractive, intelligent, with short brown hair, a slightly crooked smile, and the disconcerting ability to make a man feel he’d answered a question incorrectly even when no question had been asked.
She looked a little like Mary Beth Hurt.
Or perhaps Mary Beth Hurt looked a little like Darlene.
At my age, memory is less a reliable historical record than a committee of elderly witnesses who cannot agree on where they parked.
Darlene had been married once and worked for a regional medical supply company. She was organized, practical, and possessed an almost supernatural ability to detect when somebody was avoiding an uncomfortable conversation.
I liked her enormously.
She tolerated me with considerable affection, which I’ve always regarded as a higher achievement.
One Thursday, Darlene informed me that we would be attending a funeral on Saturday.
The deceased was her former husband’s uncle, Raymond Pritchard, whom I’d never met.
I asked why my presence was necessary.
“Because I don’t want to go alone.”
This seemed reasonable.
Then she mentioned Raymond had owned a commercial refrigeration business and his widow needed help sorting paperwork afterward.
I should have recognized the warning signs.
Any invitation involving a funeral, an ex-husband’s relatives, and commercial refrigeration equipment should be approached with the same caution normally reserved for purchasing a used Jaguar from a man who insists the electrical system has been completely sorted.
Nevertheless, I agreed.
We drove ninety miles to the funeral in my 1998 Lincoln Town Car, an automobile particularly suited to funerals, long highway journeys, and transporting women who have already decided what you’re going to do that afternoon.
Raymond had apparently been a popular man, although the minister’s description suggested his principal accomplishments involved keeping restaurant freezers operating and never missing a Rotary Club meeting.
I found this admirable.
A man who can keep a restaurant freezer operating in August has contributed more to civilization than several members of Congress.
Afterward, we attended the customary gathering in the church fellowship hall, where the ladies had assembled casseroles, potato salads, sliced ham, and a large bowl of lime-green gelatin containing cottage cheese.
I’ve never understood this culinary tradition.
Somewhere in American history, a woman discovered that gelatin could suspend solid objects and immediately decided to use the technology against her family.
After lunch, Darlene and I accompanied Raymond’s widow to the refrigeration shop.
While the women examined paperwork, I wandered into the shop and encountered Raymond’s nephew, Clifford, attempting to dispose of a commercial ice machine.
It was approximately the size of a washing machine and had once supplied ice to a seafood restaurant.
Clifford explained that it worked perfectly but nobody wanted it.
“How much ice does it make?” I asked.
“About four hundred pounds a day.”
I considered this.
Four hundred pounds seemed like an extraordinary amount of ice.
I had no conceivable use for four hundred pounds of ice.
Nevertheless, there’s something about a perfectly functional piece of machinery being offered for nothing that temporarily disables the portion of a man’s brain responsible for common sense.
“What’s he asking for it?”
“Nothing. You want it?”
I said yes.
And that was how a funeral I attended as an act of romantic consideration resulted in my becoming the owner of a commercial ice machine.
The Lincoln’s enormous trunk couldn’t accommodate it, so I borrowed a friend’s Chevrolet pickup.
Darlene emerged from the office just as we were securing the machine with ratchet straps.
She looked at the machine.
She looked at me.
“Why?”
I explained that it had been free.
“That wasn’t my question.”
I explained that it made four hundred pounds of ice a day.
“That wasn’t my question either.”
I suggested we might eventually find a use for it.
Darlene stared at me.
Then she said, “We came here to bury Raymond, not bring home his inventory.”
This was a fair observation.
But the machine was already loaded, and I’ve always believed a man should finish what he starts, particularly when somebody else provides the pickup.
We brought it home.
I installed it in my garage, connected the water supply, and discovered it did indeed produce an astonishing quantity of ice.
Within twenty-four hours, I’d filled every available cooler. Within forty-eight, I was giving ice to neighbors. By week’s end, I was supplying a church softball tournament, a family reunion, and a man attempting to keep three hundred pounds of catfish fresh until Sunday.
For approximately two weeks, I was the most popular man in the neighborhood.
Then the electricity bill arrived.
Producing four hundred pounds of ice daily apparently required the same electrical enthusiasm as operating a small aluminum smelter.
Darlene examined the bill.
Then she examined me.
“How much was that free ice machine?”
“Nothing.”
“How much is it costing us?”
I didn’t answer immediately.
She smiled.
It was not a reassuring smile.
The machine remained in my garage another six months before I sold it to a bait shop for seventy-five dollars.
I considered this a reasonable return until Darlene pointed out that I’d spent considerably more on electricity, plumbing fittings, and transportation.
Our relationship lasted another eight months.
I cannot say the ice machine caused our separation, but I suspect it contributed to a growing difference of opinion regarding the distinction between opportunity and obligation.
The last time I saw Darlene, she was driving a silver Toyota Camry.
She’d traded her old car for something newer, more reliable, and considerably less likely to arrive home carrying commercial equipment.
I’ve occasionally wondered whether she thinks about me when she puts ice in a glass.
Probably not.
But I think about her whenever I see Mary Beth Hurt.
Which explains why I’m giving Mary Beth Hurt five stars for a motion picture in which she does not appear.
I believe that’s perfectly reasonable.
What the Movie Understands About Thanksgiving

And now, having traveled from a South Carolina funeral to an ice machine in a Texas garage, we should probably return to The Big Chill.
The picture understands something important about friendship.
Old friends aren’t necessarily the people who know us best today. They’re the people who remember who we were before we learned how to present ourselves to the world.
They remember the embarrassing ambitions, improbable romances, political convictions, failures, and youthful certainty that we were destined for something extraordinary.
That’s what makes reunions uncomfortable.
We spend years constructing respectable adult identities, only to discover that somebody who knew us in college can dismantle the entire structure with one sentence about something that happened in a dormitory bathroom in 1968.
The Big Chill doesn’t pretend its characters have resolved everything by the weekend’s end. Some have made peace with their disappointments. Others have merely learned to live with them.
The characters discover that friendship doesn’t require agreement, and affection can survive the recognition that somebody you once admired has become a person you might not particularly enjoy meeting for the first time.
This makes the picture an appropriate Thanksgiving selection.
Thanksgiving is the one American holiday when we deliberately assemble people who share a common history but may have absolutely nothing else in common.
We seat them around a table, feed them excessive quantities of poultry, and hope nobody brings up something that happened in 1974.
Somebody has become successful. Somebody has been disappointed. Somebody has married badly. Somebody has divorced well. Somebody has brought a new girlfriend who doesn’t yet understand the family dynamics.
And somebody is still driving the same automobile he owned when everybody else was young.
We call this a celebration of gratitude.
And, properly understood, it is.
Because the older we become, the more we discover that the people who remember our beginnings are disappearing.
Eventually, somebody dies.
And the rest of us gather, remember, laugh, argue, and discover that the passage of time has made certain things more important than we imagined.
That is the real subject of The Big Chill.
It is the realization that our lives aren’t measured entirely by what we accomplish, but also by the people who remember us along the way.
Of course, I would have liked to see a little more of that Porsche.
Jimmy Don’s Final Verdict

THE MOVIE: 4.5 OUT OF 5 STARS
A perceptive examination of friendship, regret, aging, and the uncomfortable discovery that adulthood doesn’t necessarily confer wisdom. Excellent performances, memorable dialogue, and one of the finest popular-music soundtracks of its era.
THE AUTOMOBILES: 3.5 OUT OF 5 STARS
A satisfying assortment of American and European machinery, with the Porsche, Mercedes, Cadillac, and Jeep providing meaningful clues to their owners’ personalities. Points deducted because nobody spends enough time discussing the cars, and nobody attempts to determine whether the Cadillac’s air conditioning still works.
MARY BETH HURT: 5 OUT OF 5 STARS
An extraordinary achievement for an actress who isn’t actually in the picture. Nevertheless, she reminds me of Darlene Whitcomb, who once accompanied me to a funeral and subsequently endured six months of industrial ice production.
Some performances transcend the boundaries of the motion picture itself.
As for Thanksgiving, I recommend gathering with the people who matter, remembering those who are no longer around, and resisting the temptation to measure your life against somebody else’s accomplishments.
And if a relative offers you a perfectly good piece of commercial equipment for nothing, ask yourself whether you actually need it.
If the answer is no, thank him politely and go back to the fellowship hall.
There’s probably still some pie.
Jimmy Don Ventura
Film Critic, Automotive Observer, and Former Regional Distributor of Unnecessarily Large Quantities of Ice
Fort Stockton, Texas
P.S. If anybody knows what happened to Darlene Whitcomb, please don’t tell her I wrote this. She was right about the ice machine, and I’d prefer not to give her the satisfaction.
